The Graco has an extending headrest as well, and goes taller rear facing. I’ve never heard of a child outgrowing it by height rear facing. In fact, I’ve seen pictures of teens and small adults (all obviously over the weight limit) fitting in the tall Gracos with an inch over their head. If height is what you want, the Graco wins. The Poplar is shorter. The Poplar has 17” top harness height (the Boulevard ClickTight had 18.5”) and the Graco has 17.5”. They’re both compact. They’re both easy to install. The ClickTight is easiest, of course, but if you have ever installed a non ClickTight seat you can easily install the Extend2Fit.